The battle of attrition to raise our taxes continues at the Michigan Capitol and Republicans are standing tall in their most reasonable demand that the Democrat majority take up the numerous reforms and and spending cuts that have been offered by Republicans. The rally cry is apropos: Reform First!
Here’s the insanity of it all…the Democrats have the votes to pass their tax increase…Democrat Speaker Andy Dillon even said as much last night but said he wouldn’t pass the measure without Republican support. The real reason, I wager, is that Dillon is protecting his vulnerable members who represent politically competitive districts. Talk about political gamesmanship.
Raising personal taxes is never popular and Republicans AND Democrats are right to be extremely reticent to do so. The last time personal income taxes were increases — in 1982 — it sparked a taxpayer revolt resulting in a number of members being recalled and partisan control of the Michigan changed to the Republican column, where it has remained since.
So far, only 42 of 56 Democrats have voted in favor of HB 5194, which would raise the state’s personal income tax from 3.9 percent to 4.9 percent. Such an increase would suck up a the money used to buy a month’s groceries for an average family. That’s a huge hit for people living paycheck to paycheck, which many families are in Michigan’s single-state recession.
Here are the Dems who are not supporting their own party’s tax increase proposal:
Rep. Lamar LEMMONS Jr. (D-Detroit) was up as a no vote. The 14 Democrats not voting were, for the most part, represented vulnerable districts. They included Reps. Barb BYRUM (D-Onondaga), Terry BROWN (D-Pigeon), Ed CLEMENTE (D-Lincoln Park), Marc CORRIVEAU (D-Northville), Robert DEAN (D-Grand Rapids), Kate EBLI (D-Frenchtown Twp.), Marty GRIFFIN (D-Jackson), Richard LeBLANC (D-Westland), Gary McDOWELL (D-Rudyard), Gino POLIDORI (D-Dearborn), Mike SIMPSON (D-Jackson), Dudley SPADE (D-Tipton), Mary VALENTINE (D-Muskegon) and Lisa WOJNO (D-Warren). (This list is courtesy of the subscription-only MIRS Capitol Capsule, which offers a free tiral membership here.)
Rumors are running rampant as to what Democrat Governor Jennifer Granholm is offering a handful of Republican representatives for their ‘yes’ vote on tax increase. Some are even saying the administration is promising judicial appointments to some GOP members. Such a deal, if it is even true, would be a fool’s errand. No member could be appointed to a judicial seat while currently serving in the Legislature. And, once a member leaves his or her legislative post, what incentive is there for the governor to honor such a deal? Absolutely none.
So the arm twisting continues but Republicans continue to stand strong for Michigan taxpayers…and that’s what ultimately matters.
UPDATE:
David Freddoso over at the National Review Online has taken note of the tax-hike showdown occurring here in Lansing:
House Democratic leaders were counting on help from as many as 12 Republicans who had shown signs of weakness. But when the vote came, every Republican held firm against a tax increase and one Democrat unexpectedly voted with them. Democrats could only get 43 of their own to vote yes. [SNIP]
The House is the last line of defense for taxpayers, as the Republican-majority Senate appears certain to cave.
Technorati Tags: Michigan, Politics, Republican, Democratic, Budget+Crisis, Taxes